7.2 Metrics Are Your Early Warning System
How do you know when it’s time to pivot? Your performance metrics will tell you—if you know how to look and listen.
Warning Signs that a Pivot May Be Needed
What do warning signs look like in real life?
-
Flat or declining sales volume
Your new smartwatch sold 20,000 units in its launch month. Six months later, monthly sales have dropped to 4,000—despite ongoing promotions.
-
Price sensitivity increasing
Customers once paid $199 for your product without hesitation. Now, discount requests are common, and a competitor has launched a $149 alternative, stealing market share.
-
Rising customer acquisition costs (CAC)
You used to spend $25 on ads to gain a customer. Now it’s $60—and rising. Promotions and influencers are delivering fewer conversions than before.
-
Weak repeat purchase rates
Only 10% of customers reorder within 90 days, far below the 30% industry benchmark. First-time buyers aren’t becoming loyal advocates.
-
Negative customer feedback
Online reviews mention:
“Product looks great but broke after two months.”
“Not worth the premium price.”
“Customer service was slow and unhelpful.”
These dashboard lights don’t just tell you something’s wrong—they tell you where to go next. Few companies have followed the signals more skillfully than Netflix.
Strategy in Action: Netflix—Metrics-Driven Pivot Power
Netflix famously began as a DVD rental service. By closely monitoring customer preferences and recognizing the limitations of physical media—such as slow delivery and rising shipping costs—they identified early warning signs. Pivoting to streaming wasn’t merely a technological shift; it was a strategic response to clear customer data.
The pivot paid off!
-
Lower customer acquisition cost (CAC) through an enhanced customer experience
-
Increased repeat engagement and loyalty due to the convenience of streaming
-
Higher customer lifetime value (CLV) as subscribers consumed more content over time
In 2022, facing intensified competition and market saturation, Netflix introduced an ad-supported tier priced at $6.99 per month. This move aimed to attract price-sensitive consumers and open new revenue streams. By 2024, the ad-supported plan accounted for more than half of all new Netflix sign-ups in regions where it was available.
To further capitalize on this growth, Netflix announced plans to launch its in-house advertising technology platform by the end of 2025. This initiative is designed to enhance advertisers’ ability to buy ads, gain insights, and measure campaign impact more effectively.
Metrics are just rearview mirrors—unless you use them to steer. Netflix did more than measure success—they adjusted course in real time. That’s what it means to respond to market signals instead of chasing them.
Reuters. (2024, November 12). Netflix's ad-supported tier hits 70 million users. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/netflixs-ad-supported-tier-hits-70-million-users-2024-11-12/
Metsler, K. (2025, February 11). Netflix Advertising 2025: Guide for Marketers. Simulmedia. https://www.simulmedia.com/blog/netflix-advertising
Math Tip: What’s a Pivot Worth?
Let’s say Netflix’s average revenue per user (ARPU) for its standard tier is $15/month. By launching an ad-supported tier at $6/month, they lose $9 per user . . . right?
Not exactly.
If Netflix earns $10/month in ad revenue from that same lower-tier subscriber, they’re actually up $1 in total revenue compared to their standard plan.
Now multiply that margin across 70 million ad-supported users. That’s a $70 million/month pivot payoff. And it attracted users who wouldn’t pay $15 in the first place!
Customer Insight: Why the Pivot Worked
“I used to borrow my friend’s Netflix. I couldn’t justify the price. But once they offered the $6 plan, I signed up myself. The ads don’t bother me—I just wanted my own account.”
— Real user quote from Reddit, r/cordcutters
Sometimes, a lower-tier offering doesn’t just win back lost customers—it converts holdouts who never planned to buy at full price.
Click here to view a list of available activities.